Contact Us (301) 941-7784
American Remodel logo

Choosing the Right Roof Replacement Material for Your Home

Homeowners in Severna Park, Maryland, along with homeowners in other areas of Maryland, Virginia, or Washington DC, face the challenging task of selecting the best replacement roofing material for their homes. With a wide range of options available, the decision can feel overwhelming. To help you make an informed choice, the roofing experts at American Remodel have compiled a detailed comparison of the pros and cons of three popular roofing replacement materials: Asphalt, Metal, and Slate.

Asphalt Roof Replacement:

  • Asphalt roofs are a cost-effective/affordable option for homeowners in Severna Park.
  • They come in various colors and styles, mimicking the appearance of pricier materials, so they are highly versatile.
  • Requires periodic maintenance due to weather-related damage.
  • Low insulation if shingles become loose, impacting energy efficiency.
  • Not environmentally friendly, as production depends on fossil fuels and recycling is challenging.
  • Shorter lifespan compared to metal and slate roofing, lasting around 15-50 years.

Metal Roof Replacement:

  • Low maintenance, virtually hassle-free after installation.
  • Long-lasting, with proper care lasting up to 75 years, adding value to your home.
  • Eco-friendly, composed of recycled materials and entirely recyclable.
  • Energy-efficient, reflecting solar heat away from the building, leading to significant energy savings.
  • Comes in a variety of styles, with various metals offering unique design options.


  • Noise concerns for some, as metal roofs can be noisier during rain or hail.
  • Susceptible to denting from fallen branches or hail, requiring potential repairs.

Slate Roof Replacement:

  • Stylish, offering a classic look available in various colors, thicknesses, and widths.
  • Long-lasting, with a lifespan of 75-100+ years, making it the most durable roofing option.
  • Fireproof, unaffected by most weather conditions, and requiring minimal maintenance.
  • Dense material prevents mold and mildew growth.
  • Bigger initial investment, as slate roofing is the most expensive option.
  • Heavy weight, not suitable for all homes, requiring an experienced roofing company for installation.

How to Choose Your Roof Replacement Materials:

When deciding on a roof replacement material, consider your priorities, such as cost, lifespan, and durability. Asphalt is economical but has a shorter lifespan, while metal is durable and energy-efficient but might not be ideal for noise-sensitive households. Slate offers an elegant, long-lasting option but requires a higher initial investment and appropriate structural support.


As GAF Certified Roofers, the American Remodel team is a multi-service home improvement team here to assist with any questions or concerns related to roof replacements, whether you’re in Maryland, Virginia, or DC. Contact us or request a free quote to make the best choice for your home improvement project.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest